East Farmingdale might be best known for its central location on Long Island and proximity to the Route 110 corridor, but locals know it harbors an impressive range of eats for every palate and price point. Whether you’re hunting for the area’s crispiest slice, drooling over international street food, or craving a decades-old bakery treat, East Farmingdale delivers. Here’s your ultimate guide to the best dining and food scene hidden in this Babylon neighborhood.
Must-Visit Restaurants on Route 110
The stretch of Route 110 from Conklin Street up to Republic Airport is East Farmingdale’s main artery—and its most fertile culinary ground.
- La Piazza
*Cuisine:* Italian
*Price Range:* $$
*Location:* 512 Walt Whitman Road (Route 110)
You can’t talk East Farmingdale without mentioning La Piazza, a family-friendly spot that locals flock to for classic Italian fare. Their penne alla vodka and eggplant parm are legendary, and the gourmet pizzas (think: fig and prosciutto or classic margherita) strike the perfect balance between crispy and chewy. The open dining room is loud and lively, and portions are generous—perfect for a group dinner or Sunday lunch.
- Cassariano Italian Eatery
*Cuisine:* Modern Italian
*Price Range:* $$$
*Location:* 425 Broadhollow Road (Route 110)
More upscale than your average red-sauce joint, Cassariano leans into contemporary flavors with homemade pastas, daily seafood specials, and a surprisingly deep wine list. Their burrata starters and honey-glazed pork chop are favorites. It’s a date-night go-to, but with casual enough vibes for a family meal.
Global Flavors on Conklin Street
Just west of Route 110, Conklin Street packs a worldwide punch in a few short blocks.
- El Paso Taco
*Cuisine:* Mexican
*Price Range:* $-$$
*Location:* 1025 Conklin Street
Don’t let the unassuming exterior fool you: El Paso Taco serves up some of the most authentic tacos, burritos, and quesadillas outside of Queens. Tortillas are made fresh daily, and fillings like al pastor and barbacoa come loaded with flavor. Order at the counter and eat in, or grab a bagful for a picnic at nearby Tanner Park.
- Breakfast & Brunch at Lindencrest Deli
*Cuisine:* New York Deli
*Price Range:* $
*Location:* 965 Conklin Street
This classic NY deli is a rite of passage for locals. Early risers flock here for egg sandwiches with perfectly crisp bacon, fluffy pancakes, and coffee brewed strong enough to jolt you awake. The regulars swear by the housemade hash browns and oversized lunch heroes stacked with Boar’s Head cold cuts.
Bakeries, Cafés and Coffee Stops
No food scene is truly complete without a spot to satisfy your sweet tooth or a place to linger over coffee.
- Stuff-A-Bagel
*Cuisine:* Bakery/Bagel Shop
*Price Range:* $
*Location:* 1010 Route 110
It’s hard to beat the aroma wafting out of Stuff-A-Bagel on a Saturday morning. Bagels are boiled, then baked to chewy perfection, and the selection ranges from classic sesame to swirly marble rye. Don’t miss their homemade cream cheese (the scallion is the local favorite) or their pillowy egg sandwiches.
- Pane Dolce Bakery
*Cuisine:* Italian Bakery
*Price Range:* $
*Location:* 1196 Route 110
East Farmingdale’s best-kept secret for pastries, cannoli, and traditional Italian cookies. Their sfogliatella and rainbow cookies draw folks from all over Babylon. During holidays, expect lines out the door for fresh pies and hand-crafted cakes.
- Java Cove Café
*Cuisine:* Coffee House
*Price Range:* $
*Location:* 700 Broadhollow Road
For those who need caffeine with flair, Java Cove is the place. This cozy café serves locally roasted beans, creative lattes (try the salted caramel!), and pastry selections that change daily. It’s a favorite study spot for Farmingdale State students and a peaceful nook for remote workers.
Food Trucks & Quick Bites
The food truck scene in East Farmingdale punches above its weight, with new arrivals frequently posted up near Republic Airport or at local industrial parks.
- Taqueria San Miguel
*Cuisine:* Mexican Food Truck
*Price Range:* $
*Typical Location:* Near Republic Airport (Route 109 & Route 110 intersection)
This family-run truck draws lunch crowds for their freshly squeezed aguas frescas and overstuffed street tacos, especially the carnitas and lengua. Their homemade salsas add fire and flavor to every bite. Check their socials for daily locations.
- Grilled Cheese Please
*Cuisine:* Grilled Cheese Sandwiches
*Price Range:* $
*Typical Location:* Parking lots near Route 110/Conklin Street
Specializing in gooey, comforting sandwiches with a twist—think cheddar with caramelized onions or mozzarella with sun-dried tomatoes. Their tomato soup is a must on chilly days.
Local Traditions and Hidden Gems
Beyond the mainstays, East Farmingdale has food traditions anchored in community and history.
- Farmingdale Diner
*Cuisine:* American Diner
*Price Range:* $
*Location:* 1107 Route 110
This old-school diner is a late-night lifeline and beloved for massive pancakes, gyros, and unbeatable milkshakes. It’s a meeting place for generations of locals and visiting pilots from Republic Airport alike.
- Mamma Mia Pizza
*Cuisine:* Pizzeria
*Price Range:* $
*Location:* 1117 Route 110
While pizza options are endless, Mamma Mia is the hidden neighborhood pizzeria with the crispiest crust and sweetest sauce. Their Sicilian slice is legendary. Lunch specials keep regulars coming back.
Where to Go for a Food Crawl
If you want to sample the best in one go, start around the Route 110/Conklin Street intersection. You’re steps away from bagels, tacos, pizza, delis, and bakeries. Park your car and take a slow stroll—or hop between meals by bike.
Final Bites
East Farmingdale’s food scene might not grab headlines like Manhattan or Brooklyn, but its diversity, passion, and locally beloved spots make it a delicious destination for anyone willing to explore beyond the obvious. From longtime favorites to the freshest food truck menus, the neighborhood continues to evolve, offering new reasons for food lovers to return again and again. Next time you’re in Babylon, skip the chain restaurants—East Farmingdale’s local gems are waiting with open doors (and plenty of parking).